Not So Random Acts: Science Finds Being Kind Pays Off - Word&Way

Not So Random Acts: Science Finds Being Kind Pays Off

Acts of kindness may not be that random after all. Science says being kind pays off. Research shows that acts of kindness make us feel better and healthier. We are hard-wired to be kind.

Kindness “is as bred in our bones as our anger or our lust or our grief or as our desire for revenge,” said University of California San Diego psychologist Michael McCullough, author of the forthcoming book Kindness of Strangers. It’s also, he said, “the main feature we take for granted.”

Scientific research is booming into human kindness and what scientists have found so far speaks well of us.

“Kindness is much older than religion. It does seem to be universal,” said University of Oxford anthropologist Oliver Curry, research director at Kindlab. “The basic reason why people are kind is that we are social animals.”

Nightbird Restaurant chef and owner Kim Alter (left) mimics giving a hug to nurse practitioner Sydney Gressel (center) and patient care technician Matt Phillips after delivering dinner to them at University of California at San Francisco Benioff Children’s Hospital in San Francisco, March 27, 2020. (Jeff Chiu/Associated Press)

We prize kindness over any other value. When psychologists lumped values into ten categories and asked people what was more important, benevolence or kindness, comes out on top, beating hedonism, having an exciting life, creativity, ambition, tradition, security, obedience, seeking social justice, and seeking power, said University of London psychologist Anat Bardi, who studies value systems. It was the same in the dozens of countries she looked at: Kindness was always No. 1. People in Scandinavian countries tend to value benevolence the most and those also tend to be the happiest places in annual world rankings.

“A lot of people tell me, well, people aren’t kind. And I think that’s actually a bit of a perception fallacy because when you measure people’s behaviors, actually you find out they are kind,” Bardi said. “People do perform acts of kindness regularly.”

The trouble is we remember the unkind gesture or the rude person, not the more common and expected kindness, Bardi said. Deep down, she said, we’re motivated to be kind.

“We’re kind because under the right circumstances we all benefit from kindness,” Oxford’s Curry said.

When it comes to a species’ survival “kindness pays, friendliness pays,” said Duke University evolutionary anthropologist Brian Hare, coauthor of the new book Survival of the Friendliest. Both he and McCullough said the phrase “survival of the fittest” has been misunderstood, especially when it comes to humans.

Kindness and cooperation work for many species, whether it’s bacteria, flowers or our fellow primate bonobos. The more friends you have, the more individuals you help, the more successful you are, Hare said. For example, Hare, who studies bonobos and other primates, compares aggressive chimpanzees, which attack outsiders, to bonobos where the animals don’t kill but help out strangers. Male bonobos are far more successful at mating than their male chimp counterparts, Hare said.

McCullough sees bonobos as more the exceptions. Most animals aren’t kind or helpful to strangers, just close relatives so in that way it is one of the traits that separate us from other species, he said. And that, he said, is because of the human ability to reason. Humans realize that there’s not much difference between our close relatives and strangers and that someday strangers can help us if we are kind to them, McCullough said.

Reasoning “is the secret ingredient, which is why we donate blood when there are disasters” and why most industrialized nations spend at least 20% of their money on social programs, such as housing and education, McCullough said. Often our biggest acts of kindness come from thinking things through. When you ask people who donate live kidneys to strangers, they don’t usually talk as much about feelings but give logical reasons why they did it, McCullough said.

Duke’s Hare also points to mama bears to understand the biology of kindness and its aggressive nasty flip side. He said studies point to certain areas of the brain — the medial prefrontal cortex, temporal parietal junction, and other spots — as either activated or dampened by emotional activity. The same places give us the ability to nurture and love, but also dehumanize and exclude, he said. When mother bears are feeding and nurturing their cubs, these areas in the brain are activated and it allows them to be generous and loving, Hare said. But if someone comes near the mother bear at that time, it sets of the brain’s threat mechanisms in the same places. The same bear becomes its most aggressive and dangerous.

Hare said he sees this in humans. Some of the same people who are generous to family and close friends, when they feel threatened by outsiders become angrier. He points to the current polarization of the world.

“More isolated groups are more likely to be feel threatened by others and they are more likely to morally exclude, dehumanize,” Hare said. “And that opens the door to cruelty.”

In this Friday, April 24, 2020 file photo, Dennis Ruhnke holds two of his remaining N-95 masks as he stands with his wife, Sharon, at their home near Troy, Kansas, after he shipped one of the couple’s five masks left over from his farming days to New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo for use by a doctor or a nurse. (Charlie Riedel/Associated Press)

But overall our bodies aren’t just programmed to be nice, they reward us for being kind, scientists said.

“Doing kindness makes you happier and being happier makes you do kind acts,” said labor economist Richard Layard, who studies happiness at the London School of Economics and wrote the new book Can We Be Happier?

University of California Riverside psychology professor Sonja Lyubomirsky has put that concept to the test in numerous experiments over 20 years and repeatedly found that people feel better when they are kind to others, even more than when they are kind to themselves.

“Acts of kindness are very powerful,” Lyubomirsky said.

In one experiment, she asked subjects to do an extra three acts of kindness for other people a week and asked a different group to do three acts of self-kindness. They could be small, like opening a door for someone, or big. But the people who were kind to others became happier and felt more connected to the world. The same occurred with money, using it to help others versus helping yourself. Lyubomirsky said she thinks it is because people spend too much time thinking and worrying about themselves and when they think of others while doing acts of kindness, it redirects them away from their own problems.

Oxford’s Curry analyzed peer-reviewed research like Lyubomirsky’s and found at least 27 studies showing the same thing: Being kind makes people feel better emotionally.

But it’s not just emotional. It’s physical. Lyubomirsky said a study of people with multiple sclerosis and found they felt better physically when helping others. She also found that in people doing more acts of kindness that the genes that trigger inflammation were turned down more than in people who don’t. She said in upcoming studies she’s found more antiviral genes in people who did acts of kindness.

The overall benefit of kindness is far from a surprise to John Enzler, president of Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Washington. He said his life has been blessed by the kindness of others, so “it brings me happiness and fulfillment and great joy to feel like my random acts of kindness makes a huge difference in the lives of others.”

“It’s been all about kindness, and people pay it forward in ways beyond measure,” Enzler added.