(RNS) — The faculty of Seattle Pacific University, a Christian school associated with the Free Methodist Church, has taken a vote of no confidence in its board of trustees after members of the board declined to change its policy prohibiting the hiring of LGBTQ people.
The no-confidence vote, approved by 72% of the faculty Monday (April 19), was the latest in a series of escalating clashes between faculty, students and the school’s governing board. Faculty and students also want the school to drop its statement on human sexuality, which affirms marriage between a man and a woman as the only permitted expression of human sexuality. A total of 213 faculty voted no confidence on an online form.
Last week, about 200 students held a vigil on campus in a residential neighborhood four miles from downtown Seattle, to mourn what they called discriminatory practices toward LGBTQ people.
The board of trustees responded to the no-confidence vote Tuesday with a statement saying it would not change its employment hiring policy, which excludes LGBTQ people from full-time positions.
“The board recognizes that fellow Christians and other community members disagree in good faith on issues relating to human sexuality, and that these convictions are deeply and sincerely held,” read the statement. “We pray that as we live within the tension of this issue, we can be in dialogue with the SPU community.”
The board also indicated it was taking its stand because it wanted to continue to maintain its ties to the Free Methodist Church, a small denomination of about 70,000 in the United States and 1 million around the world. The Free Methodist Church has eight affiliated educational institutions including Azusa Pacific, Spring Arbor, and Greenville universities.
“Right now the board is the last remaining group that has not yet come to recognize that LGBTQ individuals can be faithful Christians, and as faculty and staff they would play positive roles on our campus, if we can hire them,” said Kevin Neuhouser, a professor of sociology at Seattle Pacific who is also the faculty advisor for HAVEN, the student club for LGBTQ students on campus.
Neuhouser said the school was engaged in a larger discussion of trying to discern what it means to follow Jesus.
“Is it being faithful to include or exclude?” he asked.
The most recent conflict began in January when an adjunct nursing professor filed a lawsuit accusing the university of discriminating against him and refusing him job opportunities because of his sexual orientation. Jéaux Rinedahl alleged in the lawsuit that when he applied for a full-time, tenured position as an associate nursing professor, Seattle Pacific rejected his application because he’s gay.
The status of LGBTQ faculty and students at Christian colleges and universities has been roiling many campuses.
Last month, 33 LGBTQ students or former students at federally funded Christian colleges and universities filed a class-action lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Education alleging widespread discrimination at 25 Christian colleges and universities, including Protestant, Latter-day Saint, and Seventh-day Adventist schools. One of the 33 students named in the suit included a trans man who attended Seattle Pacific, where he said he was harassed and humiliated and forced to sign a statement against his beliefs.
In 2015, two Mennonite schools, Eastern Mennonite University and Goshen College, announced they were updating their non-discrimination policies to allow the hiring of married gay and lesbian faculty. They also withdrew from the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities though they maintain their Christian identity.
The Free Methodist Church formed in 1860, when it broke away from the larger Methodist Church over slavery. Free Methodists were abolitionists who also believed in women’s ordination. In the 20th century, it became more conservative. The denomination does not contribute money to the school.
Leah Duff, a 21-year-old senior at Seattle Pacific who considers herself queer said she as disappointed in the board decisions and determined to continue to fight against the board and what she described as its discriminatory policies.
“It’s a smack in the face to have this reiterated that you want to take my money but I can’t be gay,” she said.
Duff said the students and alumni are planning a campaign to discourage donations to the school, cut its ties to community organizations and work to decrease enrollment at the school. The school does not require students to sign a sexuality statement.
Last month, 60% of the faculty at Southwest Baptist University in Bolivar, Missouri, backed a resolution expressing “no confidence” in the Board of Trustees, but it was later deemed unofficial due to procedural concerns. That vote came after trustees denied tenure or promotion to multiple professors amid a two-year controversy over theology and control.